Naming the Living Things

Image

“Name everything you can think of that is alive.”

How would you or your child respond to this prompt? Would your list be full of relatives, animals from movies and books, or perhaps neighborhood pets? Would the poppies blooming on the front steps make the list, or the oak tree towering over the backyard? And how might your list compare to that of someone from a different linguistic or cultural background, or someone with more or less contact with the natural world?

Researchers who administered this simple free-listing task to three different age groups in three disparate communities in Argentina found that the responses illuminated universal developmental processes as well as the specific linguistic and cultural forces shaping the children’s understanding of the natural world. The investigation drew its participants from a rural indigenous group of Amerindians in the Chaco forest known as the Wichí, a rural majority-culture group of Spanish speakers in the Santa Fe province, and an urban majority-culture group of Spanish speakers also living in the Santa Fe province.

In the study, conducted by Andrea Taverna of the Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientificas y Tecnicas in conjunction with our researchers at Northwestern University (as well as other researchers from the Consejo Nacional), the children were simply asked to name as many living things as they could within a several-minute time period. The comparison between the lists of Wichí speakers and Spanish speakers was of particular interest for several reasons. First, unlike many Amerindian populations, the Wichí speak their language natively from birth and typically only begin learning Spanish around age six. Additionally, as established in a survey administered as part of the study, the Wichí have more extensive direct contact with the natural world than either the rural or urban Spanish-speaking populations with whom they were compared. Finally, the Wichí have a distinct folkbiological lexicon that connects entities from the biological and spiritual world. Their phrasal description hunhat lheley, which has no precise translation in English but can be roughly understood as living things, encompasses all humans, animals, plants, and spiritual beings. The researchers wondered whether and how this unique, over-arching linguistic and cultural category might be reflected in the Wichí children’s naming process.

Children from each community were divided into three different age groups: 5- to 6-year-olds, 8- to 9-year-olds, and 11- to 14-year olds. The researchers discovered a strikingly consistent developmental trend among the different communities as well as several noteworthy commonalities across all age groups. They found that a general framework for organizing living things is in place by age five, and that this framework is enhanced over development and with experience. They also discovered that children across age groups in each of the communities focused on animals over plants, suggesting that when teaching children about plants, linking the new information to their existing knowledge of animals may be a successful approach.

In addition to these commonalities, the children’s lists also reflected their unique linguistic, cultural, and experiential backgrounds. In one analysis, researchers coded names of the animals listed as native (to Argentina), exotic, or domestic. They predicted that urban Spanish-speaking children, who get much of their knowledge about animals from media or artifacts as opposed to direct contact, would be more likely to list exotic animals than the other two groups. The results confirmed this hypothesis: the urban Spanish-speaking Children named more exotic animals and fewer natives than the rural Spanish-speaking children, who, in turn, named more exotics and fewer natives than the Wichí. The Wichí-speaking children’s lists also included far more specific biological entities from the forest, reflecting their expertise in that area. And finally, the hierarchical level of the names the children listed varied across communities, revealing differences in their familiarity with different plants and animals as well as the cultural importance attached to them. The Wichí children provided considerably more specific names for biological kinds than their Spanish-speaking counterparts, who, in turn, were more likely to provide higher-order names.

The results of this elegantly simple study demonstrate how language, experience, and culture shape children’s acquisition and organization of fundamental folkbiological concepts. With children’s developmental trajectories and particular backgrounds in mind, parents and teachers can use this information to guide children’s acquisition of biological knowledge.

The full paper can be found in the Journal of Culture and Cognition or accessed here.

 

The Boy and the Balloon: How Do Toddlers Learn Verbs?

 

9PastelYellowBalloonsIt’s a perfect spring day, and in the midst of a park full of picnic-goers and dogs playing fetch, a boy waves a yellow balloon in the air. From one corner of the park, a dad playing with his 2-year-old daughter draws her attention to the action. “I see a boy, and a balloon,” he says. “I see waving.” In another section of the park, a different dad spots the same boy with the balloon and turns to his 2-year-old daughter. “A boy is waving a balloon,” he explains, pointing to the scene. If this is the first time that either of the toddlers has ever heard the verb “waving” before, is one of them more likely to learn it than the other? A study recently conducted by Northwestern post-doctoral fellow Sudha Arunachalam (now an assistant professor at Boston University) and Professor Sandra Waxman at the Project on Child Development asks which of these ways of introducing novel verbs is most helpful to toddlers.

Though both dads have used the same words to describe the situation, the first has used what we call “sparse syntax,” meaning that the new verb isn’t embedded in a syntactically informative sentence. In contrast, the second father has used “rich syntax” to introduce the new verb. We wondered, are toddlers more likely to remember and apply the new words that they hear embedded in a syntactically rich sentence, or is the rich syntax unnecessary, perhaps even serving as a distraction that obscures the meaning of the new verb?

The 2-year-olds in our study participated in six verb-learning trials, each featuring a different “novel” verb (we use made-up verbs to ensure that the toddlers are not familiar with them). The Sparse Syntax group of toddlers heard sentences such as, “Let’s see a boy and a balloon. Let’s see pilking!” In contrast, the Rich Syntax group heard sentences such as, “A boy is gonna pilk a balloon! Let’s see!” Then, they both watched a short video clip of a boy waving a balloon. Afterwards, the toddlers were shown two different pictures, one with the same object, but a different action being performed on it (e.g., tapping the balloon), and one with the target action being performed on a new object (e.g., waving a rake). They were asked to point to “pilking.”

Although both conditions provided the toddlers with all of the semantically relevant information to understand the scene, we hypothesized that the children also given rich syntactic information would be more successful at learning the new verbs. Indeed, this was the case! The toddlers provided with Rich Syntax were much more likely to point to the Familiar Action scene than their counterparts in the Sparse Syntax group. The results provided us with two very meaningful insights: the first was that by age 2, toddlers have the remarkable ability to successfully learn new verbs and apply them to new objects and situations, even when provided with very little exposure. It also tells us, however, that toddlers need syntactically rich frames in order to more successfully do so.

The full article, currently in press, can be accessed here, and includes a description of a follow-up study comparing Sparse and Rich Semantics groups, as well as the implications for toddlers learning other native languages besides English.

What Can Story Time Teach Us?

Image

 

A 15-month-old nestled in his mother’s lap points curiously at an object in a book he’s never seen before. “Whisk,” coos his mom, answering her son’s implied query. Reading books together is a cherished bonding ritual that takes place in homes across the nation every day, but what exactly is the boy learning during these exchanges? As any parent will tell you, he will point at this same picture when Mom says “whisk” during future story sessions, but what about a real whisk he later sees at a friend’s house? The question of whether children understand that pictures represent real-life objects is at the heart of a recent study conducted at our research center at Northwestern University.

Our work was inspired in part by a previous study that first showed infants a series of pictures of white whisks and then tested whether the babies would choose a 3-dimensional blue whisk as well as, or over, a picture of a white whisk when asked to identify a whisk. Instead, the researchers found very mixed results: at test time, the younger infants were more likely to choose a picture of a white whisk and the older infants chose the picture about half of the time and a real whisk about half the time, almost never selecting both.

So does this mean that babies who see a picture in a story don’t link it to the real-life object it represents? We think they do, and we decided to test our theory at the Project on Child Development! Our researchers thought that having seen only pictures of white objects labeled as whisks might have thrown the babies off at test time—after all, there are many objects in real life, like lemons or crows, that we associate with just one color. So in our study, we read the infants a book with a series of pictures of two different colors of whisks, purple and orange.

Then we performed a series of tests where we asked them to show or give us a whisk. The results were clear: the babies overwhelmingly extended the word “whisk” to the real, three-dimensional object even though it differed in color from the picture they’d previously heard referred to as a “whisk.”

Our study clearly showed that infants as young as 15 months can map words from two-dimensional pictures onto three-dimensional objects in real life. This means that the mom we mentioned at the beginning of our post isn’t just enjoying an important bonding ritual with her son while teaching him the names of objects in a book—she is also teaching him the broader meaning of a word that will enrich his understanding of the world he is enthusiastically discovering all around him!

 Click here to read the study.